Jane Pollak Logo
jane-pollak-coaching-retreat

Jul 14, 2009

Final Headshot Vote

#1

#1 - Blue Background

#2 - white background

#1 - white background

#3

#2

Kate Eisemann, my wonderful photographer and good friend, has labored long and hard to alter the background in #1 (pale blue) and #2 (white) around my curly locks. If you haven’t already checked out her website, I highly recommend a visit and bookmarking. You can find her at http://kateeisemannpictures.photofolio.com/.

The overwhelming feedback from you turned into a very close race between #1 and #4 in my original post. Kate addressed the background issue, so here are the final three entries. Not to influence you, but, with the busy background eliminated and the other two shots previously in the running gone, I’m curious to hear your selection.

I’m deeply grateful for your input, support, kindness and time.

49 Comments

  1. Estelle

    I originally really liked #2 (formerly known as #1) mainly because of your smile and it seemed less busy. Not now. I still love the smile, but the other two jump right out at you! I’m torn, I like one with the blue background because it is very flattering, but I think it might seem a bit busy for some uses. Good luck.

    Reply
  2. Diane Schroeder

    The new #2 looks great! Kate did a fabulous job.

    Reply
  3. Karen Wiant

    Cast my vote for #2. 🙂 Karen

    Reply
  4. Christy Mitchell

    Hands down. #1 with the blue background. It enhances the coloring of your skin & makes your photo look more vibrant. “Alive” is actually the word. The other two appear to wash out your skintone and make you look pale.

    Reply
  5. Karen E. Kelley

    My choice would be #1 with the white background. You are beautiful no matter which one you pick.

    Reply
  6. donnaelle

    #1 blue background…..you are ALIVE with energy galore!

    Reply
  7. Mary Lynn

    Ranking: #1 or #2…..I think the pure white background may be too stark.

    Reply
  8. Lisa

    I’ll say #1 blue background (your skin color is more natural and glowing in that one), although I miss the original #3!

    Reply
  9. Denyse

    I still like #2 (formally #1?) the best!

    Reply
  10. Liz Carnahan

    #1 with white background. I go straight to your eyes in that one, and feel your presence and energy most directly.

    Reply
  11. Patty

    #1 – that’s my favorite – you have the best color in this one.

    Reply
  12. Marysia

    HI,
    The new 2 is perfection…..

    Reply
  13. Pam Toner

    #1 with the white background. this is my favorite.

    Reply
  14. Miriam Salpeter, Keppie Careers

    I like #1 blue or white. Maybe you need both, depending on the use? I can see the blue being too busy for some uses as Estelle mentioned. 🙂

    Reply
  15. Cookie

    I meant to tell you last night – I think #1 really jumps out. The other two are lovely but seem too sedate.

    Reply
  16. Pat Frank Sher

    Jane I LOVE LOVE LOVE #2. You come across confident, natural, art-sy & creative but that is tempered by the black wardrobe-in a nice way.

    Reply
  17. Jessica Bram

    I have to say, I really love your expression in #2. It really conveys your personality – warm and approoachable coach/friend. They are all beautiful (second choice would be #1 with white background) but there is something special conveyed in that one. You know my one quibble with it – but that may just be me.

    Reply
  18. Dave K

    Personally #1 looks warmest and friendly. Also you face has more color in that one.

    Reply
  19. Janice O'Brien

    HI Jane, All the photos show your openness, warmth and beauty. Being an Art Director, I choose 2 because you are wearing Winter colors, (the color palette to make you look best) and wearing black, white and red are colors that make you pop and look most natural. It’s fresher and crisper.

    Reply
  20. Cindy Clark

    You are beautiful not matter what! I like #1 with blue background. Maybe the white background would be better in a newspaper or black n white print.

    Reply
  21. elizabeth

    My vote is for either photo of you in dressed in blue. The colors of your wardrobe make you look vibrant and creative. I guess you could switch out the background for your desired use. Good luck…it looks like you may have opened Pandora’s Box and have too many different opinions!

    Reply
  22. Donna Frost

    Still #1 but can’t make up my mind between blue or white background. I like the positive energy, read-to-go attitude. #2 is very friendly looking but I think your tilted head doesn’t look as self-assured as #1.

    Reply
  23. Meredith Gray

    I like the clarity and vibrancy of #1. Originally thought the blue ground was too distracting but now that it has been softened I think the blue adds to the overall composition of the photo. It really makes you pop out at the viewer. It is strong and determined like you.

    #2 gets a bit soft and the photo doesn’t seem as crisp to me. Either way, you look great in all selects!

    Reply
  24. Sherry

    Hi Jane,

    Both #1’s get my vote.

    The photo with white background looks lighter overall. This makes your features softer. The mottled blue background is a bit more colorful and vibrant. I wonder if your photographer might be able to combine the softened features of the white background photo with the vibrancy of the blue background photo.

    Best,
    Sherry

    Reply
  25. Diane Overton

    I still like #3 the best (I seem to be the minority on that one!). You just look so welcoming in that picture. I also like #2, backgrounds remind me of high school photos. And whichever picture you choose, you always look fabulous!

    Reply
  26. Kelly Schellert, ASID

    I have to agree with everyone about the new #1-with pale blue background. Both #1’s jump out at you, but the white is very stark. The blue is not distracting anymore, but enhances your skin tone and plays very nicely off the red of your necklace. The whole composition of #1 with the pale blue background is the most flattering, most vibrant, and drew me in immediately.

    You could use #1 with white background for things that the blue won’t matter (like black and white newsprint) and save the pale blue background for color articles/media! 😉

    Reply
  27. debbie fay

    now i’m likeing the blue background. i vote for #1

    Reply
  28. Julianne Stirling

    I like #1 with white background. It is ‘clean’ and non distracting. All about your person.

    Reply
  29. Liz Carnahan

    Even after the background alterations on #1, I still prefer #2! I find it very welcoming.

    Reply
  30. Bonnie Jo Rohow

    Number 2 seems like Jane!!! Bonnie Jo Rohow ASID,IFDA

    Reply
  31. Barbara Rassow

    I go for #1…I like color. You look like the energetic woman you are! What does your gut tell you, Jane ??

    Reply
  32. Barbara Rassow

    For my last comment, I was referring to the first #1, with the blue background.

    Reply
  33. Olga Adler

    Hi Jane,

    #1 white background – it is so you!

    Reply
  34. cebette

    #1 with white background

    Reply
  35. Nora Kovach

    I think you look great in all three shots, but if I had to pick one it would be #1 with the white background. I think this head shot conveys confidence, and the pop of color conveys a vibrant personality.

    Reply
  36. Barbara, your sister

    #1 definitely. Sorry I didn’t weigh in earlier. They’re all nice but #1 is the best in my opinion.

    Reply
  37. Janice Weinstein

    Still like the warmth of #2…but love the fuller curls in #1…I don’t like the blue background as it reminds me of school pictures. Also…I like the idea of black and white, and a different necklace from your last head shot.

    See you soon!
    Jan

    Reply
  38. Terry Scarborough

    I like # 1 best; either background although probably prefer the white (the comments about school photos did make me think about that!) I like the direct “look in the eye” approach of #1. But for the record, my husband said “definitely #2–so obviously they are all great!

    Reply
  39. Liz Geoffrion

    I still like #1. The lighter blue is an improvement and I still think it says “Artist” and is friendly and professional.

    Reply
  40. Debra

    I like # 1 – white background

    Reply
  41. Diane

    #1 like both the blue & white background, but when I look at them individually I lean towards the white. Either way #1 & #2 are great pictures and you really will not be going wrong. Only reason I didn’t pick #2 is that your eye glasses are slightly more lowered over one eye, and since your eyes speak volumes I wouldn’t want any distractions from them….

    Reply
  42. Deborah

    Hi Jane! They all show you so well! My preference is #1 with blue background. How nice to have the flexibility to choose between them depending on where/how they will be used.

    Reply
  43. Brooke Feder

    Your photographer friend, style consultant, and parents’ gene pool all should be thanked – these are great photos. I prefer the white background #1 photo. You posess and shine a lot of color in your life, therefore I like the color to be on your person, not in the background.
    Cheers,

    Reply
  44. Margaret H. Wagner

    Dear Jane,

    I choose #1 with the blue background. It seems to feature your face best in terms of skin tone — almost warmer in a funny way.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

A GIFT FOR YOU

Want more inspiration?

Subscribe to Jane’s newsletter and receive a copy of her free report, 7 Evergreen Strategies from a Lifestyle Entrepreneur – aka Artist

You have Successfully Subscribed!